To: Foreign Interference Commission
Re: Foreign Interference Inquiry
July 26, 2024
My name is Jiajuan Zhou. I am a Chinese Canadian who has lived in Canada for over 22 years and have worked in the legal field for the past 18 years. Throughout my career, I have interacted with many Chinese Canadians who are concerned about the implications of the Public Inquiry into Foreign Interference. Thank you for the opportunity to express my concerns regarding this inquiry.
Firstly, the allegations of China interference seem to be based on claims from a few individuals of Chinese descent who lost their elections. It is important to recognize that losing an election is a normal part of the democratic process. Attributing these losses to foreign interference without substantial evidence is both inaccurate and unjust. The government should carefully evaluate these claims rather than accepting them without scrutiny. Notably, some of these individuals have historically held negative views toward China, which affects the reliability of their claims.
Secondly, based on my knowledge and understanding, Chinese culture traditionally emphasizes non-interference in the affairs of others. The notion that there is widespread interference by China in Canadian electoral processes contradicts this cultural value. In my experience as a voter, I have not encountered any evidence of interference by China in Canadian elections. My voting choices have always been based on the merits of candidates and their platforms. It should be noted that when some Canadian volunteers encourage voters to support their preferred candidates, this should not be considered “foreign interference.” Such activities are part of the democratic process and should not be conflated with foreign influence.
Thirdly, focusing disproportionately on the interference by China may adversely affect the Chinese Canadian community. Such an approach can create an environment of fear and discrimination, leading to unjust stigma against Chinese Canadians. This is particularly concerning in given the rise in Anti-Asian hate crimes driven by misinformation and xenophobia. I have observed that some Chinese Canadian have been attacked without evidence.
Additionally, Canada is a country built on immigration, with people coming from various parts of the world. Many Canadians maintain ties with their countries of origin. The focus on “China interference” has caused Chinese Canadians to fear contacting their relatives back home, which is a violation of fundamental human rights. Such an environment of fear is both unjust and inhumane.
Moreover, if the emphasis on “China interference” is influenced by geopolitical competition, there is a risk that Canada could be unduly influenced by other countries. It is essential that our actions prioritize the best interests of all Canadians and are not swayed by external geopolitical pressures.
Balancing national security interests with the protection of our diverse communities is crucial. We must ensure that our actions do not unintentionally foster fear or discrimination. By adopting a careful and inclusive approach, we can work towards a safer and more equitable society for everyone.
In conclusion, while addressing foreign interference is important, the inquiry should not unfairly target the Chinese community based on unverified claims. A balanced and evidence-based approach will help ensure that the inquiry does not harm the diverse communities that contribute to our society. I trust that you will consider these points as you expand public consultation.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Your truly,
Jiajuan Zhou
